You’re spending $5,000, $10,000, maybe $15,000 a month on Google Ads. You’re getting leads. But you’re not getting clients — or at least not enough of them to justify the spend. Your agency sends you a report every month. It shows impressions, clicks, and cost per click. But your signed cases aren’t moving.
Before you fire your agency, read this. Four of the seven signs below are genuine agency failures. Three of them look like agency failures but are actually intake problems. Knowing which is which saves you time, money, and a difficult conversation.
Signs That Point to the Agency
Sign 1: No Conversion Tracking Beyond the Form Fill
If your agency’s definition of a conversion is a form submission, they are optimizing for the wrong outcome. A form fill is not a client. An agency that is not tracking call conversions, consultation bookings, and — ideally — retained clients is flying blind and will optimize for lead volume rather than lead quality.
Sign 2: Ads Driving Traffic to Your Homepage
PPC ads should send traffic to dedicated landing pages that match the ad’s message and have one clear call to action. If your ads are sending traffic to your general homepage, your conversion rate will be a fraction of what it should be. This is a basic error that indicates the agency is not approaching your account with proper methodology.
Sign 3: Reports Full of Marketing Metrics, No Business Metrics
If your monthly report shows impressions, click-through rate, cost per click, and quality score — but nothing about cost per consultation, consultation rate, or conversion to retained client — your agency is reporting on their work, not your results. A good agency reports on the numbers that matter to your business.
Sign 4: No Proactive Communication Between Reports
A PPC account needs active management. Bids change. Competition changes. Seasonal patterns shift. If you only hear from your agency when the monthly report arrives — and never proactively about changes in performance or strategy adjustments — your account is likely on autopilot.
Signs That Look Like Agency Failures But Aren’t
Sign 5: Leads Are Coming In But Not Converting
This feels like an agency problem — they’re generating leads that don’t convert, so the leads must be bad. Sometimes that’s true. But often, the leads are fine and the conversion problem is in intake: slow response time, no follow-up sequence, a consultation process that doesn’t close.
Before blaming your law firm PPC agency, check your response time data and your consultation-to-retained rate. If either is weak, fix those first before changing your PPC strategy
Sign 6: Cost Per Lead Is High
High cost per lead is sometimes an agency efficiency problem. But it can also reflect a competitive market, a niche practice area, or a geographic targeting decision that is correct strategically but expensive in practice. Ask your agency to benchmark your CPL against industry averages for your practice area before concluding it is too high.
Sign 7: Call Volume Is Up But Signed Cases Are Flat
Calls are up but clients aren’t. This pattern almost always points to intake, not ads. The agency is delivering volume. Something in your intake process — response time, follow-up, consultation close rate — is not converting that volume into revenue. Increasing your ad budget in this scenario makes the problem more expensive, not better.
What to Do
If you identified genuine agency failures: have a direct conversation. Share your business metrics — not just their marketing metrics. Ask for a specific improvement plan with a 60-day timeline. If nothing changes, find an agency that manages to business outcomes.
If you identified intake failures: don’t touch the agency yet. Fix intake first. Improve your response time, build your follow-up sequence, and review your consultation process. Then reassess the marketing performance once the intake system is working.
The fastest way to improve your marketing ROI is often not to change your marketing. It’s to fix what happens after the lead arrives.
| Not sure whether your problem is your agency or your intake process? Let’s find out.
Book your free 15-min strategy call at getgoinginbusiness.com |
Related: How to Organize Your Law Firm’s Marketing Vendors & Stop Wasting Money →